As we’re working towards fixing up our house, we’ve dismantled some of the “work” the previous owners put into it.
One thing to know, before you try anything home-reno-ish… is that walls are never square. Floors are never level.
Back to the previous owners, then. Every time we pull out baseboards, flooring, lighting fixtures, or seemingly anything at all… we pull out thick, long strands of beige caulking. It’s like every gap they ever made, they just filled with caulk. Ran out of floorboards? No problem, fill in that 2-inch gap with caulk. The base of the new light fixture is too small for the existing hole? No worries, caulk the crap out of it… nobody will notice. No transition strip installed? Caulk. I’m surprised they didn’t patch the cracks in the driveway with caulk. (side note: “caulk” jokes are still funny to me… I’m not so sure Mama Monkey finds them as amusing, but she humours me)
Flash-forward to our current project, the renovation of our powder room. We searched for something to re-purpose as a vanity for months. We weren’t that picky; a used washstand, the right size of dresser, an oversized nightstand… almost anything would have done the trick. But alas, in the end we ended up getting something from The Home Depot (big surprise!). Exactly the right size, exactly the right look, and since the powder room was never meant to be our piece de resistance, we didn’t mind that it’s the same veneered particle board that people eventually upgrade OUT of. It was still an upgrade compared to what was there.
In any event, several problems arose, which we eventually solved. The important thing to note is that NONE of these involved using caulking:
- At some point in time, new tiles were installed, but they only went to the edge of the previous vanity, leaving a “drop” when we ripped the old one out. Built up the “drop” area with plywood and a hardboard cover, and are planning to cover a remaining exposed gap with tile, hardwood, or stick-on tile. Not caulk.
- walls are not square (they’re more like 92 degrees), so cabinet is not square. The back is more important, so we made that flush, and will fill the remaining gap in the front with a thin custom-sliced wedge of wood. Not caulk.
- the same walls… not square… mean that the one-piece “cultured marble” (aka concrete with a ceramic glaze) top was not a fit. Had to use a flap-sanding disc in an angle grinder to create a “92 degree” angle from back to front, making the top a fit against the back and side walls. The right way to do it… not a cop-out by filling with caulk.
- The top has a built-in backsplash but no “side-splash”. This will be made with glass tiles. But the top has a gentle curve leading into the built-in backsplash, which left a pretty big gap between the tiles and the back. Could just stick on the tiles, but I refuse to caulk it all up. Took out a rotary tool and ground (grinded? I should look that up) a recess for the tile. Still not abso-smurfly perfect, but anything more would have been excessive and pedantic. Bottom line: no caulk beyond the required.
I’m not against caulk of course. I just think you need to use it where it’s supposed to go. Like, NOT as a replacement floorboard or a driveway patch.
Greg
“CAULK CAULK CAULK CAULK” (juvenile, but fun!)